1960

Johnny Romano

Willie McCovey

Pumpsie Green

Jim Baxes

Joe Koppe

Bob Allison

Ron Fairly

Willie Tasby

Jim Perry

Jim O’Toole

1961

Jimmie Coker

Jim Gentile

Julian Javier

Ron Santo

Ron Hansen

Tony Curry

Tommy Davis

Frank Howard

Chuck Estrada

Dick Stigman

1962

Joe Torre

J. C. Martin

Jake Wood

Charlie (Charley) Smith

Dick Howser

Floyd Robinson

Lee Thomas

Billy Williams

Don Schwall

Jack Curtis

1963

Bob Rodgers

Fred Whitfield

Bernie Allen

Ed Charles

Tom Tresh

Manny Jimenez

Al Luplow

Boog Powell

Dean Chance

Al Jackson

1964

Jesse Gonder

Rusty Staub

Pete Rose

Pete Ward

Al Weis

Vic Davalillo

Jimmie Hall

Tommy Harper

Ray Culp

Gary Peters

1965

Mike Brumley

Bob Chance

Hal Lanier

Richie (Dick) Allen

Bert Campaneris

Rico Carty

Tony Conigliaro

Tony Oliva

Wally Bunker

Bill McCool

1966

Pat Corrales

Tony Perez

Joe Morgan

Paul Schall

Rico Petrocelli

Curt Blefary

Jose Cardenal

Ron Swoboda

Frank Linzy

Marcelino Lopez

1967

Randy Hundley

George Scott

Davey (Dave) Johnson

Tommy Helms

Sonny Jackson

Tommie Agee

Byron Browne

Cleon Jones

Jim Nash

Woody Fryman

1968

Dick Dietz

Lee May

Rod Carew

Bobby Etheridge

Tim Cullen

Rick Monday

Reggie Smith

Walt Williams

Dick Hughes

Tom Seaver

Rich Nye

1969

Johnny Bench

Gary Holman

Dave Nelson

Ken Boswell

Bobby Cox

Hector Torres

Bobby Bonds

Dave Marshall

Del Unser

Stan Bahnsen

Jerry Koosman