1990

Bob Geren

Carlos Martinez

Gregg Jefferies

Craig Worthington

Gary Sheffield

Greg Briley

Ken Griffey, Jr.

Jerome Walton

Tom Gordon

Jim Abbott

1991

Sandy Alomar, Jr.

Hal Morris

Delino DeShields

Robin Ventura

Jeff Huson

Felix Jose

David Justice

Larry Walker

Kevin Appier

Scott Radinsky

1992

Ivan Rodriguez

Jeff Bagwell

Chuck Knoblauch

Leo Gomez

Andujar Cedeno

Milt Cuyler

Luis Gonzalez

Ray Lankford

Mark Leiter

Al Osuna

1993

Todd Hundley

Eric Karros

Jeff Kent

Scott Livingstone

Pat Listach

Moises Alou

Kenny Lofton

Reggie Sanders

Cal Eldred

Dave Fleming

1994

Mike Piazza

J. T. Snow

Carlos Garcia

Mike Lansing

Wil Cordero

Jeff Conine

Wayne Kirby

Tim Salmon

Greg McMichael

Steve Cooke

1995

Javy Lopez

Bob Hamelin

John Patterson

Jose Oliva

Chris Gomez

Ryan Klesko

Raul Mondesi

Manny Ramirez

Joey Hamilton

Brian Anderson

1996

Charles Johnson

John Mabry

Ray Durham

Chipper Jones

Orlando Miller

Garret Anderson

Marty Cordova

Shawn Green

Hideo Nomo

Carlos Perez

1997

Jason Kendall

Tony Clark

Tony Batista

Joe Randa

Derek Jeter

Jermaine Dye

Todd Hollandsworth

F. P. Santangelo

Alan Benes

Billy Wagner

1998

Scott Hatteberg

Dmitri Young

Wilton Guerrero

Scott Rolen

Nomar Garciaparra

Jose Cruz, Jr.

Jose Guillen

Andruw Jones

Jason Dickson

Mike Holtz

Tony Saunders

1999

A. J. Hinch

Todd Helton

Miguel Cairo

Bob (Bobby) Smith

Mike Caruso

Ben Grieve

Mark Kotsay

Magglio Ordonez

Kerry Wood

Jesus Sanchez