2000

Ben Davis

Brian Daubach

Warren Morris

Corey Koskie

Alex Gonzalez

Carlos Beltran

Chris Singleton

Preston Wilson

Billy Koch

John Halama

2001

Bengie Molina

Pat Burrell

Adam Kennedy

Mike Lamb

Rafael Furcal

Terrence Long

Jay Payton

Mark Quinn

Kazuhiro Sasaki

Mark Redman

2002

Shawn Wooten

Craig Wilson

Alfonso Soriano

Albert Pujols

Jimmy Rollins

Adam Dunn

Tsuyoshi Shinjo

Ichiro Suzuki

Roy Oswalt

C. C. Sabathia

2003

Geronimo Gil

Nick Johnson

Mark Ellis

Eric Hinske

Ramon Santiago

Austin Kearns

Alex Sanchez

Brad Wilkerson

Jason Jennings

Damian Moss

2004

Miguel Olivo

Robby Hammock

Mark Teixeira

Bo Hart

Ty Wigginton

Angel Berroa

Rocco Baldelli

Jody Gerut

Scott Podsednik

Brandon Webb

Dontrelle Willis

2005

Joe Mauer

Adam LaRoche

Aaron Miles

Chad Tracy

Khalil Greene

Jason Bay

Matt Holliday

Terrmel Sledge

Daniel Cabrera

Mike Gonzalez

2006

Brian McCann

Dan Johnson

Tadahito Iguchi

Garrett Atkins

Russ Adams

Jeff Francoeur

Jonny Gomes

Willy Taveras

No Rookie Cup On Card

Huston Street

Gustavo Chacin

2007

Russell Martin

Prince Fielder

Dan Uggla

Ryan Zimmerman

Hanley Ramirez

Melky Cabrera

Andre Ethier

Nick Markakis

Justin Verlander

Francisco Liriano

2008

Carlos Ruiz

James Loney

Dustin Pedroia

Ryan Braun

Troy Tulowitzki

Delmon Young

Chris Young

Hunter Pence

Brian Bannister

Hideki Okajima

2009

Geovany Soto

Joey Votto

Alexei Ramirez

No Heritage Rookie Cup Card Issued

Evan Longoria

Mike Aviles

Jay Bruce

Denard Span

David Murphy

Brad Ziegler

John Lannan