2010
Omir Santos
Travis Ishikawa
No Rookie Cup on card
No Heritage Rookie Cup card issued
Chris Getz
No Rookie Cup on card
Gordon Beckham
Elvis Andrus
Chris Coghlan
Andrew McCutchen
Nolan Reimold
No Rookie Cup on card
Tommy Hanson
No Rookie Cup on card
J. A. Happ
2011
Buster Posey
Gaby Sanchez
Neil Walker
Danny Valencia
Starlin Castro
Team Card
Austin Jackson
Giancarlo (Mike) Stanton
Jason Heyward
Stephen Strasburg
Jaime Garcia
Jose Tabata
Heritage Rookie Cup card issued but not officially at Topps winner
Neftali Feliz
2012
J. P. Arencibia
No Rookie Cup On Card In Base Set
Rookie Cup Short Print
Mark Trumbo
Danny Espinosa
Brett Lawrie
Dee Gordon
Desmond Jennings
Josh Reddick
No Rookie Cup On Card
SP with Rookie Cup Logo
Ben Revere
Jeremy Hellickson
Craig Kimbrel
2013
Wilin Rosario
Anthony Rizzo
Steve Lombardozzi
Todd Frazier
Zack Cozart
Yoenis Cespedes
Bryce Harper
Mike Trout
Yu Darvish
Wade Miley
Addison Reed
2014
Evan Gattis
Matt Adams
Jedd Gyorko
Nolan Arenado
Jose Iglesias
Wil Myers
Yasiel Puig
Christian Yelich
Jose Fernandez
Hyun-jin Ryu
Jim Henderson
2015
Travis d’Arnaud
Jose Abreu
Kolten Wong
Nick Castellanos
Xander Bogaerts
Billy Hamilton
Danny Santana
George Springer
Masahiro Tanaka
Roenis Elias
Dellin Betances
2016
J. T. Realmuto
Justin Bour
Addison Russell
No Rookie Cup on card
Chrome – No Rookie Cup on card
Kris Bryant
Carlos Correa
Michael Conforto
No Heritage Rookie Cup card issued
Randal Grichuk
Kyle Schwarber
Noah Syndergaard
Carlos Rodon
Roberto Osuna
Miguel Sano
No Heritage Rookie Cup card issued
2017
Gary Sanchez
Tommy Joseph
No Rookie Cup on card
Ryan Schimpf
No Rookie Cup on card
Alex Bregman
Corey Seager
Nomar Mazara
Tyler Naquin
No Rookie Cup on card
Trea Turner
No Rookie Cup on card
Kenta Maeda
No Rookie Cup on card
Julio Urias
No Rookie Cup on card
Seung-hwan Oh
No Rookie Cup on card
2018
Manny Pina
Cody Bellinger
Ian Happ
Rafael Devers
Paul De Jong
Andrew Benintendi
Aaron Judge
Trey Mancini
German Marquez
Jordan Montgomery
Josh Hader
2019
Jorge Alfaro
Ryan O’Hearn
No Heritage Rookie Cup card issued
Gleyber Torres
Miguel Andujar
Willy Adames
Ronald Acuna Jr.
Harrison Bader
Juan Soto
Walker Buehler
Ryan Yarbrough
A. J. Minter
Shohei Ohtani
Yankeesman's Quest for the Cup 