2020

Will Smith

Pete Alonso

Keston Hiura

Vladimir Guerrero Jr.

Fernando Tatis Jr.

Eloy Jimenez

Bryan Reynolds

Victor Robles

Mike Soroka

John Means

Nick Anderson

Yordan Alvarez

2021

Sean Murphy

Jared Walsh

Jake Cronenworth

Alec Bohm

Willi Castro

No Cup On Card

Luis Robert

Kyle Lewis

Ryan Mountcastle

No Heritage Rookie Cup card issued

Tony Gonsolin

Kwang Hyun Kim

Devin Williams

2022

Tyler Stephenson

Ryan Mountcastle

Jonathan India

Patrick Wisdom

Wander Franco

Randy Arozarena

Adolis Garcia

Dylan Carlson

Luis Garcia

Trevor Rogers

Emmanuel Clase

2023

Adley Rutschman

Joey Meneses

Brendan Donovan

Bobby Witt Jr.

Jeremy Pena

Michael Harris II

Julio Rodriguez

Steven Kwan

Spencer Strider

Reid Detmers

Alexis Diaz

Vinnie Pasquantino

2024

Yainer Diaz

Spencer Steer

Matt McLain

Gunnar Henderson

Josh Jung

Corbin Carroll

James Outman

Nolan Jones

Masataka Yoshida

Kodai Senga

Andrew Abbott

Yennier Cano

2025

Austin Wells

Michael Busch

Colt Keith

Joey Ortiz

Masyn Winn

Jackson Merrill

Jackson Chourio

Colton Cowser

Wyatt Langford

Paul Skenes

Shota Imanaga

Mason Miller